Luggage - Carry-on Baggage
Traveling light is an art that I confess I’m still a long way from mastering. For those of us with past neck or back injuries, choosing the right carry-on can make all the difference when traveling. Whether you prefer a comfortable backpack or a rolling case, finding the right balance of convenience, organization, and ease of handling is key. Let’s explore the best options for a functional and lightweight carry-on, with insights from Marigolds who’ve navigated the world and made different choices.
Backpacks
For those who find it challenging to lift a rolling suitcase into an overhead bin, a well-designed travel backpack can be a game-changer. The ideal backpack should be lightweight yet spacious enough to carry all essentials comfortably. Look for features like:
A padded compartment for electronics – If you travel with an iPad or laptop, a dedicated sleeve offers added protection.
Exterior water bottle pocket – Staying hydrated while on the go is essential, and an easy-to-reach bottle holder is a must.
Multiple compartments for organization – Keeping everything in its place prevents the frustration of digging through your bag mid-flight.
A light-colored interior – A bright or lightly lined interior makes it easier to find items, especially in dim lighting.
Separate pockets for a phone and keys – Quick access to these essentials saves time and frustration at security checks and in transit.
Tabs or D-rings - For hanging items that don’t fit inside
Anna (67), swears by her lightweight travel backpack. “When I visited Morocco, I quickly realized that rolling luggage wasn’t ideal for the medinas. The dirty streets and steep stairs were a nightmare for wheeled bags. My backpack let me navigate easily, and I had everything I needed within reach.”
Rolling Carry-Ons: Pros and Cons
If you’re like me and carrying weight on your back isn’t an option, a rolling carry-on could be the way to go. These bags allow you to move through airports effortlessly while freeing up your hands for a smaller personal item. However, they do come with some drawbacks:
Extra weight – Rolling bags often weigh more than backpacks due to the wheels and handle mechanism.
Less interior space – The retractable handle and wheel wells reduce packing capacity compared to a backpack of similar dimensions.
Maneuverability concerns – While great for smooth airport floors, wheeled bags can be tricky to handle on cobblestone streets, narrow staircases, or crowded public transport.
Versatility - While rolling bags are great in many respects, they lack versatility once you reach your destination. A backpack can be used as a daypack, whereas a rolling bag can not.
Lisa (72), prefers a rolling carry-on, despite some challenges. “I love my two-wheeled carry-on, but Rome’s cobblestone streets were tough. I ended up lifting it more than rolling! Still, I’d rather pull my bag than carry it on my back, so it works for me. Also, I invested in a strong bag so when I have to sit and wait and in a que, I can do so on my bag.”
Soft-Sided vs. Hard-Shell Luggage
When choosing a rolling carry-on, another decision to make is whether to go with a soft-sided or hard-shell suitcase.
Soft-sided bags tend to be more lightweight, flexible, and slightly more forgiving when packing an extra item or two. They also often feature external pockets for quick access to travel documents or small items.
Hard-shell suitcases offer better protection for fragile items and are generally more durable. However, they are usually heavier and provide less flexibility in terms of storage.
Hybrid options combine the best of both worlds—offering hard-shell protection with exterior pockets for added convenience. They are more expensive though and sometimes, even heavier!
Margaret (65), opted for a hard-shell suitcase on a trip to Thailand. “It was great for protecting my souvenirs, but the weight became an issue when I had to lift it onto ferries between islands. If I were doing it again, I’d try and be more ruthless regarding what I pack and possibly try to get a bag that is a backpack with wheels and a handle… or pay someone to help me,”
Are Four-Wheeled “Spinners” Worth It?
Spinner suitcases, with four multi-directional wheels, are popular because they glide smoothly across airport floors with minimal effort. However, they may not be the best choice for every traveler. The downsides include:
Fragility – Spinner wheels are more exposed and prone to breakage.
Run-aways – Unlike two-wheeled rolling bags, spinners can easily roll away on inclines.
Limited usability on uneven terrain – While great on smooth floors, they struggle on cobbled streets and rough paths.
Sophie (58), tried using a spinner suitcase in Paris. “It was amazing in the airport, but once I hit the cobblestones near my Airbnb, it became a pain. The wheels got caught in cracks, and I ended up dragging it like a regular two-wheeler anyway.”
Tips for Choosing the Perfect Carry-On
Once you’ve decided on the type of bag that suits your needs, consider the following factors:
Quality matters – Opt for a well-reviewed brand with a reputation for durability. While you don’t need to spend a fortune, a well-made bag can withstand years of travel.
Choose a practical color – Darker colors tend to hide wear and tear better than bright shades, but bright colors are easier to spot and for airlines to locate if lost.
Check airline restrictions – Some international budget airlines have stricter carry-on size and weight limits than U.S. airlines. Always check baggage policies before booking your ticket.
Use compression packing cubes – These help compress clothes, keep items organized, and prevent the frustration of rummaging through your bag mid-trip. Be sure to invest in good compression cubes, not regular ones.
Final Thoughts
The best travel bag is the one that fits your personal needs and travel style. Whether you prefer a backpack for hands-free convenience or a rolling carry-on for easy transport, choosing a lightweight, well-organized option will make your journey smoother and more enjoyable. Looking at what other older women travelers use is a great way to discover new options. Happy travels!
